National Politics

Judge Refuses To Throw Out Trump Classified Documents Case, Calls Special Counsel Request ‘Unjust’

On Thursday, Judge Aileen Cannon dismissed another request by former President Donald Trump (R) asking to throw out his classified documents case.

Much of the noise surrounding the case has centered on if Trump has the ability to use the Presidential Records Act (PRA) to defend himself in the upcoming case. Trump argues that the PRA gave him jurisdiction to choose which of the documents were his personal records and which were not.

Cannon has not expressed her views on the former president's ability to invoke the act. Nevertheless, she ruled that his prosecutors made no reference to the PRA.

Special counsel Jack Smith has been pushing for the judge to rule on if Trump can use the act, but Cannon stated that the calls to rule on the usage of the PRA were “unprecedented and unjust.” If she were to rule that the PRA could be used, then Smith could appeal to Florida's 11th Circuit.

Trump recently referred to Smith as “deranged” and having a “history of failure”. The former president’s gripe with the special counsel stems from his desire to have the Trump-appointed judge, Cannon, removed from the case.

The former president has been charged with 37 counts, 31 of which he is accused of making false statements, conspiracy to obstruct justice, withholding a document or record, corruptly concealing a document and willful retention of national defense information.

Smith found issues with the judge’s recent jury instructions which he stated “rest on an unstated and fundamentally flawed legal premise” and that “the question of whether the PRA [Presidential Records Act] has an impact on the element of unauthorized possession under Section 793(e) does not turn on any evidentiary issue, and it cannot be deferred. It is purely a question of law that must be decided promptly.”

Smith continued, “If the Court were to defer a decision on that fundamental legal question it would inject substantial delay into the trial and, worse, prevent the Government from seeking review before jeopardy attaches.”

Joshua Smith

Joshua Smith is a writer and recent graduate, majoring in English.

Recent Posts

Texas Education Agency Takes Over Fort Worth ISD

The Texas Education Agency (TEA) will remove the Fort Worth Independent School District’s elected board…

12 hours ago

Tony Gonzales Planning Another 'SUCCESSFUL' Re-Election Bid

Texas Rep. Tony Gonzales (R) is facing a whirlwind as he navigates the upcoming 2026…

13 hours ago

Energy Vault Acquires 150 MW Energy Center in Texas

Energy Vault Holdings, Inc. announced its acquisition and planned development of the SOSA Energy Center,…

14 hours ago

Ted Cruz, John Cornyn Introduce Bill to Strengthen Vetting of Unaccompanied Minors

U.S. Senators Ted Cruz (R) and John Cornyn (R) have introduced the Kayla Hamilton Act.…

17 hours ago

LONESTAR — 10.24.2025 — Cornyn, Hunt Call Each Other 'Fake MAGA' — Crocket Weighing Texas Senate Run — and More...

Hunt Dubs Cornyn 'Fake MAGA' in Heated Republican Primary Attorney General Ken Paxton (R) and…

17 hours ago

Hunt Dubs Cornyn 'Fake MAGA' in Heated Republican Primary

Attorney General Ken Paxton (R) and Rep. Wesley Hunt (R) are vying for the U.S.…

2 days ago