The Computer & Communications Industry has raised concerns regarding a proposal bill in Texas, Senate Bill 2420, which mandates online platforms to implement age verification measures for users. While the bill’s aim is to protect children online, the CCIA warns that the bill could have unintended consequences for privacy, access, and families, particularly in underserved communities.
SB 2420 requires platforms to use tools such as facial age estimation, or to collect sensitive personal data, like driver licenses, to verify the age of users. While the intention is to protect children from the dangers online, the CCIA emphasizes the potential downsides of these measures. For instance, facial age estimation has been criticized by experts for producing inconsistent results across different demographic groups. This inaccurate age assessment could prevent legitimate users from accessing the platform, or conversely, allow underage individuals to bypass restrictions.
The bill will also allow for private lawsuits with limited protection, which the CCIA argues could result in costly litigation even in cases where no harm has occurred. Several laws implementing similar requirements in other states have already been blocked by courts due to First Amendment and privacy issues.
State Policy Manager for the CCIA, Tom Mann, released a statement arguing that citizens should not have to give up personal data, when the technology fails to work.
“We all want to keep kids safe online, but it’s important that policies reflect how technology actually works. This bill relies on age estimation tools that still have substantial gaps in accuracy.” Said Mann. “When those tools don’t work, families are left having to give over personal data instead.”
Mann continued, asking Texas lawmakers to take a balanced path that protects children while also safeguarding privacy and upholding constitutional protections.
As lawmakers continue to review SB 2420, the CCIA advocates for a balanced approach to protecting children online and addressing privacy concerns.
